PERSONAL 10"

4 Slices

$7.99

SMALL 13"

8 Slices

$12.49

LARGE 16"

16 Slices

$15.25

This is the recipe that put us on the map all those years ago. It has been passed down for generations and still stands the test of time.



  • CUP & CHAR PEPPERONI
  • PEPPERONI
  • MUSHROOMS
  • SAUSAGE
  • ONIONS
  • ANCHOVIES
  • PINEAPPLE
  • HAM
  • MEATBALLS
  • SWEET PEPPERS
  • BANANA PEPPERS
  • HOT CHERRY PEPPERS
  • BLACK OLIVES
  • GREEN OLIVES
  • DICED TOMATOES
  • ARTICHOKES
  • EGGPLANT
  • BACON
  • CARAMELIZED ONIONS
  • SPINACH
  • BROCCOLI
  • *FETA CHEESE
  • *GRILLED CHICKEN
  • *BUFFALO CHICKEN
  • *SHAVED STEAK
  • *CRUMBLY BLUE CHEESE

EACH ADDITIONAL TOPPING

PERSONAL 1.00 | SMALL 1.75 | LARGE 2.50

*PREMIUM TOPPINGS ADD: PERSONAL $1.50 | SMALL $3.00 | LARGE $4.00

*SHEET 25”X17”

26 PIECES

MOZZARELLA 25.00
EACH ADDITIONAL ITEM 3.50

*24” BIG ROUND

32 SQUARE PIECES OR 12 PIE CUT

MOZZARELLA 25.00
EACH ADDITIONAL ITEM 3.50

*THIS SIZE IS NOT AVAILABLE IN OUR DINING ROOM

ORIGINAL

SWEET SAUCE

WHITE SAUCE Blended with garlic, herbs and Romano

TRAY SAUCE Crushed tomatoes, garlic,herbs and Romano

personal $9.99 • small $16.99 • large $21.00

PORKZILLA

Our sweet sauce, mozzarella, bacon, ham & Italian sausage

WHITE TRADITIONAL PIZZA

A Batavia favorite. Spiced garlic ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli & spinach

BACON CHICKEN RANCH

Our house made ranch dressing, grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese

THE HAWAIIAN

Sweet pizza sauce with sweet pineapple ham & mozzarella cheese

STEAK IN THE GRASS

Our white sauce topped with shaved steak, spinach & mozzarella cheese

BACON CHICKEN RANCH

Our house made ranch dressing, grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese



ITALIAN MEAT

Traditional pizza sauce topped with homemade meatballs. Italian susage, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese

THE GREEK

White sauce topped with spinach, tomatoes & feta cheese

SIENNA

Our white sauce with grilled chicken, breaded eggplant, mozzarella & crumbly bleu cheese

THE PICKLE PIZZA

Balsamic glaze, mozzarella and pickles

THE HOT SICILIAN

Our signature tray sauce, mozzarella, capicola, pepperoni & hot cherry peppers

THE ITALIAN VEGETABLE

Our sauce, mozzarella, broccoli, tomatoes, sweet peppers & onions.



TRADITIONAL MOZZARELA & WHITE RICOTTA    8.25

CREATE YOUR OWN

Each additional item   .75   CHICKEN additional   1.75

ITALIAN MEAT   9.99

Ricotta | Mozzarella | Italian Sausage | Pepperoni | Onion | Sweet Pepper

PHILLY CHEESE STEAK   9.99

Grilled Steak | Sweet Peppers | Onions | Mozzarella

PIZZA, MOZZARELLA & PEPPERONI   9.99

BUFFALO CHICKEN   9.99  w/ side of bleu cheese

Mozzarella | Chicken Tender Pieces | Choice of BBQ, Medium or Hot Sauce

VEGETARIAN   9.99

Ricotta | Mozzarella | Broccoli | Spinach | Onion | Sweet Pepper

HOT SICILIAN   9.99

Capicola | Hot Peppers | Pepperoni | Tray Sauce





GARLIC KNOTS W/ MARINARA5.99

LOADED FRIES TOPPED W/ CHEESE & BACON8.50 w / ranch

PIZZA LOGS W / MARINARA (4)7.99

GARLIC BREAD3.99
w/ cheese 4.99

BRUSCHETTA BREAD $7.99

CHICKEN TENDERS W/ CHOICE OF SAUCE7.99
with fries 8.99

DEEP FRIED PICKLES W /RANCH (7)6.99

MOZZARELLA STICKS W/ MARINARA (6)6.99

CHICKEN WING DIP W/ TORTILLA CHIPS6.99

SAMPLER PLATTER (3ea. Pizza Logs, Mozz Sticks, Chicken Fingers 9.99

HODGE PODGE Deep Fried Veggies & Cheeses with Bleu cheese and Celery 9.99

BASKETS

ONION RINGS 3.99

WAFFLE FRIES 3.79

CHEESY TOTS 3.79

CHICKEN WINGS

BBQ, Medium, Hot, Boss, Italian Rub, Bee’s Knees Bourbon, Sweet & Sour, Garlic Parm, Raspberry, N’awlins Blues, Cattleman's Gold
Served Bleu Cheese & Celery & Carrots

Half Order - (5 wings) 5.99

Single (10 wings) 10.99

Double (20 wings) 19.99

*Bucket (40 wings) 34.99

*TAKEOUT & DELIVERY ONLY

BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS 

BBQ, Medium, Hot, Boss, Italian Rub, Bee’s Knees Bourbon, Sweet & Sour, Garlic Parm, Raspberry N’awlins Blues
Served Bleu Cheese & Celery

Single 8.75

Double 16.50





NUTS ABOUT SPINACH SALAD

Spinach, Pecans, Walnuts, Dried Cranberries, Crumbly Bleu Cheese, Balsamic Vinaigrette 9.99

ANTIPASTO

Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, Cubed Cheeses, Green Bell Peppers, Chickpeas, Olives, Lettuce, Italian Dressing 9.99

CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD

Chicken, Caeser Dressing, Parmesan, Croutons  9.99

BUFFALO CHICKEN

Breaded Chicken, Medium Sauce, Crumbly Blue Cheese, Celery, Tomatoes, Romaine Lettuce, Bleu Cheese Dressing . 9.99

STEAKHOUSE

Shaved Steak, Crumbly Blue Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers, Onions, Italian Dressing  9.99

GARDEN SALAD

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers, Chickpeas, Olives, Croutons, Pepperoncini, choice of dressing
FULL 6.99   HALF 4.75
add Grilled Chicken or Steak 2.25


ITALIAN WEDDING - cup 2.99 bowl 3.99

SOUP OF THE DAY - cup 2.99 bowl 3.99

THE CLUB   10.99

Turkey, Bacon, Ham, Provolone, Pesto Mayo & Tomato

CHICKEN BACON RANCH   10.99

Chicken breast, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese & Ranch Dressing

THE SICILIAN   10.99

Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, & our signature Italian dressing

THE RED ROOSTER   10.99

Chicken Breast, Spinach, Roasted Red Pepper & Feta cheese

All Paninis come with A Pickle and Pasta Salad





ALL SUBS ARE TOASTED

small           large  

BAKED HAM & CHEESE

MAIN ASSORTED
Ham | Salami - add Cappicola .50/1.00

HARVESTER TURKEY (Turkey,Ham)

BLT

CHEESE SUB
Provolone | Mozzarella

TURKEY

TUNA

6.99

6.99

6.99

6.99

6.99

6.99

6.99

8.25

8.25

8.25

8.25

8.25

8.25

8.25

*Make any large sub a wrap

Add a side of Pasta Salad $2.00

MEATBALL PARMIGIANA
Homemade Meatballs | Tomato Sauce

SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA
Cheese | Marinara

EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA

PIZZA SUB
Cheese | Pepperoni | Tomato Sauce

CHICKEN FINGER
(PLAIN, BUFFALO)

ROYAL SUB
(Sausage & Cappicola)

DAN’S FAVE STEAK & CHEESE

NEW GRILLED CHICKEN

CHEESEBURGER

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

7.99

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

9.25

All subs include choice of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, house Italian dressing, mayonnaise Cheese: Provolone, Mozzarella, American, Pepper Jack, Cheddar

BLACK & BLUE WRAP
SHAVED STEAK, CARMELIZED ONIONS, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, CRUMBLY BLUE CHEESE, GARLIC MAYONNAISE SERVED WITH CHIPS 8.99

BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP
MEDIUM BUFFALO CHICKEN TENDERS, TOMATOES, LETTUCE, AND BLUE CHEESE DRESSING. SERVED WITH CHIPS 8.99

CRANBERRY CHICKEN WRAP
CHICKEN TENDERS, GRAPES, DRIED CRANBERRIES, CHEDDAR, LETTUCE, WALNUTS, HONEY RANCH DRESSING. SERVED WITH CHIPS 8.99

CHICKEN CAESER WRAP
with grilled chicken 8.99


PLEASE REQUEST SEPARATE CHECK BEFORE ORDERING
15% GRATUITY FOR PARTIES OF 12 OR MORE


BATAVIA'S ORIGINAL PASTA BOWL

WE ARE NOT JUST PIZZA! A HEAPING PORTION OF SPAGHETTI OR PENNE COOKED TO ORDER AND TOSSED WITH OUR HOMEMADE SAUCE, A RECIPE THAT HAS STOOD THE TEST OF TIME.   9.99
with Homemade Meatballs or Sausage  11.99
with Broccoli, Fresh Garlic and Olive Oil  11.99
with Gluten Free Penne  $7.99

HOMEMADE MEAT LASAGNA

LAYERS UPON LAYERS OF PASTA, LOCALLY MADE ITALIAN SAUSAGE, HOMEMADE MEATBALL, MOZZARELLA, RICOTTA, ROMANO, AND PARMESAN CHEESES BAKED IN OUR HOMEMADE PASTA SAUCE.   13.99

FETTUCINI ALFREDO

IMPORTED FETTUCINE PASTA TOSSED WITH OUR CREAMY ALFREDO SAUCE MADE IN-HOUSE.   Chicken 12.99 | Shrimp 14.99

CHEESE STUFFED RAVIOLI

FRESH PASTA PILLOWS STUFFED WITH RICOTTA AND IMPORTED PARMESAN CHEESES. TOPPED WITH OUR HOMEMADE SAUCE.   11.99

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA

   12.99

EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

   12.99

 

Desserts by Joanne Rock:

HOMEMADE ITALIAN COOKIES - 6 / 4.99
Assorted or White Ricotta

HOMEMADE CHEESECAKE - 4.99
Plain or Spumoni

More Sweets

PIZZA FRITE - Sprinkled with confectionary sugar and cinnamon 4.75
for Dipping - Chocolate Sauce | Caramel 1.00

CHEESE CANNOLIS - 2.49

CHOCOLATE DIPPED CANNOLIS - 2.99

APPLE LOGS$4 (3) logs served with a side of Caramel ADD VANILLA ICE CREAM 1.00

SIGNATURE SHAKESVanilla | Chocolate | Strawberry | Peanut Butter | Banana | Orange Cream | Loganberry | Mint | Cherry | Blue Raspberry

SLUSH PUPPIESRegular 2.49  Kids 1.49

500 East Main Street, Batavia, NY 14020   •   (585) 343-3303

Home    |    Menu    |    History    |    Coupons    |    Contact Us    |    Directions    
Photography by MADesigns will make you happy